In my many years on this planet I’ve taken both piano and guitar lessons. However, most of this time was spent learning the two instruments in a variety of ways: listening to recordings, jamming with guys better than me and watching bands.I learned piano from a teacher from an early age and then it slide in favor of the tenor banjo because the folk era was big. Although I never picked piano up again for more than 10 years what did stay with me was the technique: how to hold my hands.
Guitar, on the other hand, was mostly self-taught and I have a lot of bad habits as a result. Taking classical guitar lessons helped immensely and I restructured my hand positions. Later on I lost the left hand technique but I still have the “PIMA” positioning when I finger pick with the left hand.
And I watch pickers who could be a lot more effective if they weren’t resting their hands on the top of the guitar and turning their hands in a more sideways attitude. There are lots that do this and it cuts down on finger mobility.
Now-a-days you can learn rock guitar or jazz piano at specialized classes from the get-go. Gone are the Mel Bay books (although there were some good technique drills in those books) where you learned the notes playing The Old Gray Goose. In fact my kids all learned piano from professional teachers and have better technique than the old man.
And guess what? An old dog and a new trick - now that’s a stretch.






Stumble it!